Home Attorneys Practice Areas Legal Links Contact Us


Cheer for Trademarks

by Geoff Mantooth

Originally publised in the Fort Worth Business Press

  A few weeks ago, Fort Worth played host to national cheerleading competitions. Literally thousands of cheerleaders mingled around downtown, a sight to see. To a lay reporter, who happens to be male, it was also totally confusing. Expecting to see the SuperBowl of pre-collegiate cheerleading, this turned out to be only one of several national competitions.

  You'd never have known it from the high levels of enthusiasm though. The cheerleaders mingling outside of the convention center bounced with nervous energy, their faces lit with excitement. It was enough to compensate for the vacuum cleaner known as the ticket office. How can an organization charge so much for an amateur sporting event? If our kids weren't there, we wouldn't go, and that's a fact.

  Competitive cheerleading takes some knowledge to watch and understand. First lesson, just because the ticket prices are high doesn't mean that the seats are any good. The cheerleaders performed on what looked like a large wrestling mat. Their entire routine is played to a tiny audience of judges who are surrounded by quite a bit of empty space. Way to the back of the judges are seats for the ticket payers. Sitting in the wings got you closer to the cheerleaders, but you only saw their sides, since they faced the judges. Sitting in the wings also meant that you felt the full effect of the loudspeakers.

  Second lesson, competitive cheerleaders don't lead any cheers. The music is so loud that the audience couldn't hear cheers anyway. Besides, the audience cheers for the cheerleaders, a fact that took some getting used to.

  Make no bones about it, the kids worked hard to whip up enthusiasm. They came out like championship wrestlers, arms moving up and down to milk the crowd. They moved to their positions, waited for the music to start and then tumbled by doing back handsprings and flips. They'd perform timing routines, where two girls tumbled on colliding paths. A slight miscount and they'd do full contact cheerleading. They'd throw one of their number up in the air and catch her again, all the while wearing enormous smiles to show everyone how much fun they were having.

  When not competing against one another, cheerleaders are the visual element of an intangible aspect of sports organizations. They represent the goodwill of the club. And goodwill is what trademarks are all about.

  Trademarks are used to distinguish one product from another. In a sport where there are more than one national championships, trademarks prove particularly valuable. The Fort Worth competition was hosted by America 's Best, and boy anyone who entered the convention center knew it. The America 's Best logo was plastered everywhere, even to the point of a projection of the logo on the backdrop of the wrestling, or performing, mat. That backdrop logo happened to be perfectly positioned so as to fall within the field of view of the cable TV cameras filming the event and the still photos capturing pictures of the kids for resale of their historic trip to nationals.

  Another lesson involved trophies. Positioned beneath the projected logo were a slew of trophies. Unlike the SuperBowl, America 's Best nationals had more categories than most of us could ever believe possible. The reporter learned from a mom on another, much bigger, team just how much money some folks spend on the sport, for the coaches, uniforms and all kinds of other necessary stuff. One has a natural tendency to be smug, confident in the belief that only those other teams spent all that money… until informed otherwise by the spouse. Family CFO's ask, why are we doing this? Statistically the most common answer given by supportive moms is that colleges award cheerleading scholarships. Not that anyone knows anyone else who ever snagged such a thing.

  America 's Best happens to be an unregistered trademark, meaning that the company has common law rights to the mark. A quick search of the Trademark Office revealed why, with so much at stake, the mark was unregistered. The Trademark Office lists several hundred America 's Best registrations and attempted registrations. The mark is so common it's used on some un-cheerleader products, like cigarettes. Now that would make an interesting tie-in.

  Not that the popularity of the mark matters. For these 13-18 year olds, one has the impression that other products branded America 's Best fall into another world. The cheerleaders know the difference between America 's Best and their rival Cheer Power. All of which leads to the last lesson, know thy market.

  The preliminaries were on a Saturday with the final competitions the next day. More than two-thirds of the teams made the finals and the remainder were invited back for consolation performances. All the better to boost the gate revenue from parents who are afraid to say no. For family CFO's the trademark takes on a different meaning altogether.

  That's why the sweetest part of the event were the words, “Dad, I don't want to do this next year.” No argument there.

Originally published in the Fort Worth Business Press

 

Originally Published in the Fort Worth Businss Press